gang-of-4-patterns AT lists.siebelschool.illinois.edu
Subject: Design Patterns discussion
List archive
- From: "ziane" <mikal.ziane AT lip6.fr>
- To: "'Paul Adolph'" <padolph AT lsil.com>, <gang-of-4-patterns AT cs.uiuc.edu>
- Subject: RE : [gang-of-4-patterns] Strategy Pattern vs. Bridge Pattern
- Date: Fri, 7 Nov 2003 00:21:10 +0100
- Importance: Normal
- List-archive: <http://mail.cs.uiuc.edu/pipermail/gang-of-4-patterns/>
- List-id: Design Patterns discussion <gang-of-4-patterns.cs.uiuc.edu>
Indeed the Problem part of a pattern is essential.
But the problem that a pattern addresses is often difficult to identify
clearly. It is often mixed up with the pattern's solution.
For instance the Intent section seems a bit ill-named since it does
include the solution.
There are also sometimes different problems adressed by the same
pattern.
Hence I would not trust too much what is communicated through a
pattern's name in documentation.
Hence I think that designers should make their quality objectives and
principles explicit and then document which mechanisms (e.g. refactoring
transformations) where used to enforce them.
Patterns are great but not enough.
- [gang-of-4-patterns] Strategy Pattern vs. Bridge Pattern, Chris Finlayson, 11/05/2003
- Re: [gang-of-4-patterns] Strategy Pattern vs. Bridge Pattern, Wayne Cannon, 11/06/2003
- RE: [gang-of-4-patterns] Strategy Pattern vs. Bridge Pattern, Paul Adolph, 11/06/2003
- RE : [gang-of-4-patterns] Strategy Pattern vs. Bridge Pattern, ziane, 11/06/2003
- RE : [gang-of-4-patterns] Strategy Pattern vs. Bridge Pattern, Paul Adolph, 11/06/2003
- RE : [gang-of-4-patterns] Strategy Pattern vs. Bridge Pattern, Mikal Ziane, 11/07/2003
- RE : [gang-of-4-patterns] Strategy Pattern vs. Bridge Pattern, Paul Adolph, 11/06/2003
- RE : [gang-of-4-patterns] Strategy Pattern vs. Bridge Pattern, ziane, 11/06/2003
- RE: [gang-of-4-patterns] Strategy Pattern vs. Bridge Pattern, Paul Adolph, 11/06/2003
- Re: [gang-of-4-patterns] Strategy Pattern vs. Bridge Pattern, Wayne Cannon, 11/06/2003
- <Possible follow-up(s)>
- RE: [gang-of-4-patterns] Strategy Pattern vs. Bridge Pattern, Ray Ye, 11/06/2003
- RE : [gang-of-4-patterns] Strategy Pattern vs. Bridge Pattern, Mikal Ziane, 11/06/2003
- RE: RE : [gang-of-4-patterns] Strategy Pattern vs. Bridge Pattern, Chris Finlayson, 11/06/2003
- RE: RE : [gang-of-4-patterns] Strategy Pattern vs. Bridge Pattern, David Rosenstrauch, 11/06/2003
- State and strategy [was RE : [gang-of-4-patterns] Strategy Pattern vs. Bridge Pattern], Peter Horan, 11/06/2003
- Re: State and strategy [was RE : [gang-of-4-patterns] Strategy Pattern vs. Bridge Pattern], Wayne Cannon, 11/06/2003
- Re: RE : [gang-of-4-patterns] Strategy Pattern vs. Bridge Pattern, Wayne Cannon, 11/07/2003
- RE: RE : [gang-of-4-patterns] Strategy Pattern vs. Bridge Pattern, Chris Finlayson, 11/06/2003
- RE : [gang-of-4-patterns] Strategy Pattern vs. Bridge Pattern, Mikal Ziane, 11/06/2003
- Re: [gang-of-4-patterns] Strategy Pattern vs. Bridge Pattern, Wayne Cannon, 11/06/2003
Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.16.